Mystic Hill Olde Barn

Specializing in Amish Wares and Country Gifts

Along with our many country & rustic gifts, we also have a large selection of moose, bear, chicken, cow and pig items for sale.

Some of the chicken & rooster products in the barn
Some of the products in the barn
Some of the products in the barn

We're Closed Until April

If you have a special item that you're looking for then please call us.

We're Redeveloping our Website!


New Bed & Breakfast Coming Soon!

Bed & Breakfast

Details Coming Soon! »

horse & buggy
Green Amish Bonnet

Store Hours

April, May & Nov., Dec.

Thursday - Saturday 10 am - 5 pm

Closed Sun thru Wed.

June - October

Tuesday thru Saturday 10 am - 5 pm

Closed Sun & Mon

When we're closed

On days and hours we are not open,
we ask that you please call
(716) 912-0981.

 I am only 5 min. away from the store.

Pillow 41
Pillow 42
Pillow 43

Payment Options

Cash, Checks, Mastercard, Visa and Discovery gladly accepted.

(No chickens or goats please)

Heat & Air Conditioning

Sorry, we do not have heat or air conditioning, we are not the mall! We are a restored 150 year old barn.

If you want the mall, we can give you directions. If you just want to think you're at the mall, we can double your bill at check out.
Thank you.
Papa Moose


Come and enjoy the rolling hills of the Enchanted Mountains of Western New York State (Cattaraugus County) and the ambiance of our local Amish Community.

Free maps of the local Amish Farms available.